Shadow of the Erdtree’s Game of the Year Nomination Ignites Debate: Is it Fair Play or a Rule-Breaking Move?

November 21, 2024 Controversy has always been a part of the Game Awards, which honor the top video games each year. This year, Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree’s surprising candidacy for the coveted Game of the Year award is the main focus. Despite being an unquestionable masterpiece, the DLC’s eligibility for the top prize has been questioned, sparking a heated discussion among gamers.

A Nomination Never Seen Before Sparks Controversy

The Game Awards have historically honored stand-alone games with the Game of the Year title. A recent regulatory change, however, has made it possible for DLCs and expansions to compete with full-fledged games. With Shadow of the Erdtree’s nomination, a DLC is being considered for the top accolade for the first time, setting a precedent that has divided opinions.

Questionable Eligibility: Is It a Standalone Experience?

The topic of whether Shadow of the Erdtree is a stand-alone experience is at the center of the debate. Critics contend that the DLC cannot be evaluated separately because it is inextricably linked to the main game, Elden Ring. They argue that the nomination goes against the essence of the Game of the Year award, which has long honored comprehensive and independent gaming experiences.

In addition, there have been questions about the regulation change’s timing. After Shadow of the Erdtree was released, it was announced that DLCs would be eligible for Game of the Year, which led some to believe that the rules were changed especially to make room for the much-awaited expansion.

An Outstanding Work Deserving of Acknowledgment?

On the opposing side of the argument, proponents of the nomination contend that Shadow of the Erdtree deserves praise for its outstanding merits, regardless of its format. They cite the DLC’s vast new regions, difficult bosses, and gripping plot as proof of its worth on its own.

Fans also point out that DLCs have long been honored in Game of the Year categories at other award events, like the esteemed D.I.C.E. Awards. They contend that the addition of DLCs to the Game Awards is a positive move in recognizing the increasing significance of post-release content in the gaming sector.

Rigging Charges and an Imminent Retaliation

Accusations of rigging have been made in the debate surrounding Shadow of the Erdtree’s nomination. Some gamers think that the game’s developer, FromSoftware, or publisher, Bandai Namco, manipulated the nomination. Others contend that the organizers of the Game Awards are purposefully stirring up controversy to increase interest in the occasion.

If Shadow of the Erdtree wins Game of the Year, the criticism of the nomination is likely to get more intense. Critics caution that such a result would undermine the honor’s reputation and create a risky standard for nominations in the future.

The Game Awards 2024 will be held on December 7th, where the winner of the Game of the Year award will be announced. The gaming world will be watching with bated breath to see if Shadow of the Erdtree makes history or becomes a controversial footnote in the awards show’s history.

Click on the images below to own designs

Contact us

Homepage: The Iconhawaiian

×
×